Screening girls for breast most cancers from their 40s relatively than their 50s may save lives with out including to the analysis of innocent cancers, a UK examine has discovered.
The analysis was primarily based on 160,000 girls from England, Scotland and Wales, adopted up for round 23 years.
Lowering screening age may save one life per 1,000 girls screened, the scientists say.
But specialists warning there are numerous different issues, together with price.
Cancer Research UK says it’s nonetheless “not clear if reducing the breast screening age would give any additional benefit compared to the UK’s existing screening programme”.
The charity says the precedence ought to be getting most cancers companies “back on track” for ladies aged 50-70, after disruption attributable to the pandemic.
During lockdown, most cancers screening programmes which detect early indicators of bowel, breast and cervical most cancers have been paused in Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland, though not formally stopped in England.
Experts have warned of enormous backlogs for screening, therapy and exams.
Currently within the UK, girls between the ages of 50 and 70 are invited to be screened for breast most cancers each three years.
Women under 50 are usually not routinely provided screening as a result of their danger of breast most cancers is usually very low and their breast tissue is extra dense, making it troublesome to learn the outcomes of mammography exams used to identify cancers.
This can result in over-diagnosis – detecting very early cell modifications which can not flip into problematic cancers – and the potential for exposing girls to pointless therapy.
Writing within the Lancet Oncology, the scientists say they discovered a discount in breast most cancers deaths from screening girls of their 40s yearly over the primary 10 years they have been tracked.
In the group of 53,883 girls of their 40s who have been screened, there have been 83 deaths, in comparison with 219 deaths within the 106,953 girls of the identical age who weren’t screened.
The discount in deaths got here from detection of grade 1 and a couple of cancers, which may progress extra rapidly in youthful girls.
After 10 years, any proof of additional lives being saved tailed off, the researchers stated.
They additionally discovered a “modest over-diagnosis in this age group” which was just like that discovered within the over-50s.
In the examine, 18% of ladies who went for screening of their 40s had at the very least one false constructive outcome.
- Pandemic may trigger 1000’s extra most cancers deaths
- ‘More than two million in UK look forward to most cancers care’
Prof Stephen Duffy, lead researcher, from Queen Mary University of London stated: “This is a very long-term follow-up of a study which confirms that screening in women under 50 can save lives,
“In the fullness of time, it’s value occupied with decreasing the age of screening.”
However, he said the financial cost of this should be taken into account, and more research was needed into the impact of modern screening equipment on diagnoses.
Sophia Lowes, health information manager at Cancer Research UK, said the charity had concerns about the study results.
“Many girls acquired false constructive outcomes and a few girls would have been over-diagnosed with cancers that may by no means have gone on to trigger them hurt,” she said.
“While analysis into bettering our screening programmes stays very important, screening programmes are already underneath enormous pressure as a result of pandemic, and the precedence proper now ought to be getting companies again on monitor for ladies aged 50-70.”
The charity calculates that six instances extra girls of their 40s, in comparison with these aged 50-70, would have to be screened to avoid wasting one life.
Ms Lowes stated it was necessary that ladies – regardless of how outdated they’re – ought to nonetheless inform their physician in the event that they observed something uncommon about their breasts.