Despite crimson flags raised by officers of potential battle of curiosity and propriety, contracts value Rs 6 crore got to companies promoted by educationist Pramath Raj Sinha by the “Railway University” whilst Sinha is a member of the Board of Management of the identical college run by Indian Railways.
Sinha’s firm, 9dot9, of which he’s founder and managing director, has been awarded a consultancy contract for the National Rail and Transportation Institute (NRTI), a deemed college of the federal government, value Rs 65 lakh per thirty days plus GST for 9 months ending December 2021, in keeping with data reviewed by The Indian Express.
This occurred regardless of Railways officers flagging the potential battle of curiosity in written deliberations and pointing in the direction of attainable circumvention of provisions of the General Financial Rules (GFR) of the federal government which, particularly, take care of battle of curiosity in consultancy contracts.
Sinha, the founding Dean of Indian School of Business, is among the many founders and trustees of Ashoka University. He has been intently concerned in establishing the NRTI, a deemed to be college and loosely termed the “Railway University” in Vadodara.
Sinha’s 9dot9 consultancy can be the strategic companion of US foyer agency Albright Stonebridge Group, chaired by Madeleine Albright, former US Secretary of State.
Incidentally, that is the second contract given to Sinha’s companies by the institute the place he’s a part of the highest administration crew.
Last 12 months, Harappa Education, of which Sinha can be the Founder and Managing Director, obtained an project to impart coaching to Railway officers on administration practices and Artificial Intelligence. Sources stated that engagement is for round two years and fee is on the idea of participation of officers. So far, round Rs 40 lakh has been launched, sources stated.
In the case of 9dot9, the Railway Board accepted the contract on April eight after officers put down in writing that it should adjust to the “conflict of interest” provisions laid down within the GFR.
Significantly, in June, too, this was flagged once more when the engagement of 9dot9 was to be formalized by way of paperwork involving RITES —the Railway PSU engaged by Railway Board to execute the matter.
The GFR provisions cited by officers particularly mandate that the advisor employed ought to strictly keep away from conflicts with different assignments or his/its personal company pursuits and performing as a right for future work.
The provisions say that it’s a battle of curiosity if the bidding agency or any of its associates are both concerned within the consultancy contract to which procurement is linked.
Records present that RITES knowledgeable the Railway Board that the choice to interact 9dot9 was arrived at after aggressive bidding and due diligence.
When requested for his touch upon the contracts, Sinha referred The Indian Express to Alka Arora Misra, interim Vice Chancellor of NRTI, and stated she is “the best and most appropriate person to speak” on this.
When contacted, Misra, who can be Railway Board Additional Member (Human Resources), conveyed by way of a Railway ministry spokesman that every one contracts have been awarded as per rules and due course of.
The “Railway University” was a undertaking envisaged within the first time period of the Narendra Modi authorities. Railways carved out the NRTI from the prevailing infrastructure within the sprawling campus of National Academy of Indian Railways in Vadodara.