The Real Problem Revealed By The Brett Favre Welfare Scandal


Former NFL quarterback Brett Favre might have improperly siphoned hundreds of thousands of {dollars} in welfare funds for his personal pet venture, in response to the state of Mississippi and courtroom paperwork.

Favre is the highest-profile determine caught within the Mississippi welfare scandal, during which the state funneled $77 million of Temporary Assistance for Needy Families funds to folks with political connections.

But there’s an excellent larger scandal right here: Nationwide, most TANF cash doesn’t go to poor folks within the first place.

Just 22% of program funds went to money help in 2020, in response to an evaluation of state and federal knowledge by the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, a liberal suppose tank. The bulk of the remainder of the cash paid for little one care, coaching applications, tax credit and administration of this system itself.

The Favre case “is absolutely an egregious example of the pitfalls that are inherent in TANF today,” Aditi Shrivastava, a senior coverage analyst with the CBPP, stated in an interview.

Why does this system most carefully related to the phrase “welfare” spend so little cash on precise money welfare? Because that’s how Congress needed it.

In the 1990s, Democrat Bill Clinton ran for president on a pledge to “end welfare as we know it,” and Republican Newt Gingrich grew to become House Speaker partly by promising a “Contract with America” that included welfare cuts. Together they eradicated an open-ended federal entitlement for low-income moms, known as Aid to Families with Dependent Children, and in 1996 changed it with TANF, a set annual grant permitting states to design their very own applications.

The legislation restricted the period of advantages, required states to sanction mother and father who fail to adjust to “work requirements,” and rewarded states for conserving their caseloads down. In 1996, greater than two-thirds of households in poverty acquired advantages, whereas simply 21% did as of 2020, in response to CBPP. Only 1,000,000 households acquired month-to-month funds that yr.

Welfare reform additionally gave states leeway to set advantages, and states with bigger percentages of Black residents have been much less doubtless to supply money.

Mississippi, a state with one of many largest Black populations, has lengthy had one of many least beneficiant TANF applications, spending simply 5% of its program {dollars} on funds to households. The most month-to-month profit for a household of three there’s simply $260, with eligibility restricted to these with month-to-month revenue beneath $680. Just 2,300 Mississippi households acquired money advantages within the common month of 2020. Meanwhile, the state was sitting on $47 million in unspent funds.

“Mississippi should be providing a lot more cash assistance to a lot more families,” Shrivastava stated.

Welfare politics has modified for the reason that 1990s, with Democrats now favoring unconditional money help that doesn’t deny advantages to the unemployed. And for a quick time through the coronavirus pandemic, even Republicans supported simply giving cash to the poorest of the poor. Sen. Mitt Romney (R-Utah) even proposed scrapping TANF as a part of a plan to present all mother and father within the U.S. a month-to-month little one allowance as a substitute. But proposals to overtake the security web alongside these traces have stalled.

The TANF program has continued buzzing alongside within the background, the worth of its $16 billion federal block grant steadily eroding with inflation.

Favre allegedly acquired about $1 million from nonprofits that acquired TANF grants from Mississippi, and he allegedly tried to steer hundreds of thousands extra towards building of a volleyball stadium at his daughter’s faculty.

The former director of the Mississippi Department of Human Services and several other folks related to the nonprofits have pleaded responsible for his or her roles within the fraud scheme, which was initially uncovered by a state auditor in 2020.

Favre hasn’t been charged with against the law. He paid the cash again, and has stated he had no concept it was presupposed to be for one thing else. But even when it hadn’t gone to Favre’s checking account, it in all probability wouldn’t have gone to a needy household both.