‘The worry is Russia’: UN delays Myanmar illustration choice


Bangkok, Thailand and Yangon, Myanmar – The United Nations has delayed a call on who ought to characterize Myanmar amid concern that Russia, which has change into more and more near Myanmar’s coup leaders, may sabotage efforts to reach a global consensus on the crisis-torn nation.

The UN’s Credentials Committee, composed of 9 UN-member states, together with China, Russia and the United States, began assembly on November 29. Under consideration is who ought to characterize Myanmar: sitting UN Ambassador Kyaw Moe Tun, appointed by the elected authorities of chief Aung San Suu Kyi, or a nominee of the generals who staged the coup that overthrew her authorities in February 2021.

The committee will submit its suggestions to the United Nations General Assembly (UNGA), which normally rubber stamps the recommendation given.

The query over Myanmar’s UN illustration displays the added difficulties going through the anti-coup motion at a time when geopolitical tensions have escalated after Russia’s invasion of Ukraine.

Described as “two authoritarian powers… operating together” by NATO Secretary-General Jens Stoltenberg, the break up between Russia and China on one facet, and different components of worldwide group has widened, analysts say, and strongman Vladimir Putin and Chinese chief Xi Jinping have proven much less urge for food to compromise.

Despite that, the US, China and Russia would most likely want to not have a public spat over Myanmar’s illustration, mentioned veteran diplomat and former Dutch ambassador to Myanmar Laetitia van den Assum.

“These powers have enough major issues on their plates as it is. At the same time, however, China and Russia would no doubt like to see Kyaw Moe Tun go.”

Diplomat Moe Kyaw Tun Making The Three Fingered Salute Of Myanmar'S Anti-Coup Movement At A Un Meeting Five Days After The Military Seized Power. He Is Sitting At The Myanmar Desk In The Un General Assembly
Kyaw Moe Tun, who famously made the three-fingered salute of the anti-coup motion contained in the UNGA, stays the nation’s consultant [United Nations via YouTube and AFP]

Kyaw Moe Tun, who remained in his publish after the coup, voted this yr to sentence Russia’s invasion of Ukraine and to droop Russia’s membership on the UN Human Rights Council. He is backed by Myanmar’s National Unity Government (NUG), established by the nation’s elected and now-removed legislators.

Both Beijing and Moscow have publicly backed senior normal Min Aung Hlaing’s pariah regime, at the same time as nations in Southeast Asia toughened up their previously-lukewarm pushback towards the navy. More than 2,500 folks have been killed within the navy’s crackdown because it seized energy in February 2021, based on the Assistance Association for Political Prisoners, a civil society group monitoring the scenario.

The UN Credentials Committee had initially agreed to maintain Kyaw Moe Tun for an additional yr, based on a Western diplomat concerned within the course of. “The worry all along is Russia,” the diplomat mentioned.

Now that the choice has been delayed, critics fear that it opens the door for Russia to choose a battle on behalf of the internationally-isolated Myanmar navy. Failure to reach a consensus on the committee would result in a vote within the UNGA.

“Moscow could be problematic, should they choose to be. While they accepted the NUG to control the representation in the UN in 2021, Russia is in a very different place diplomatically today following their invasion of Ukraine and their military setbacks,” Zachary Abuza, a professor on the National War College within the US who focuses on Southeast Asian politics.

“I don’t want to overstate Naypyidaw’s importance to Moscow. It is a second-tier client-state, but today Russia has few friends, and Min Aung Hlaing has been sycophantic towards President Putin, in his desperate attempt to garner international legitimacy.”

Cosying as much as Putin

Moscow has been actively supporting the navy, inviting Min Aung Hlaing to Russia, shielding the regime from UN Security Council sanctions, and offering arms and petroleum.

“Beyond the re-appointment of Kyaw Moe Tun in the UN, Russia is being difficult to work with [in terms of reaching a consensus in the international community to pressure the regime] and is publicly backing the junta. China seems to be consolidating its support for the regime as well,” mentioned Scot Marciel, former US ambassador to Myanmar.

“It’s different from 2021. They provide tangible support for the junta, whereas those who support the resistance and the anti-coup movement are more rhetorical in their support.”

Min Aung Hlaing And Vladimir Putin Shake Hands At A Summit In Vladivostok, Russia. They Look Pleased To See Each Other And Are Smiling. The Flags Of Myanmar And Russia Are In The Background.
Myanmar navy chief Min Aung Hlaing secured a longed-for assembly with Russian President Vladimir Putin on the sidelines of the 2022 Eastern Economic Forum in Vladivostok, Russia, in September [Valery Sharifulin/TASS via AFP]

Min Aung Hlaing met Putin for the primary time because the coup in September on the sidelines of the Moscow-organised Eastern Economic Forum (EEF) in Vladivostok, a metropolis within the far east of Russia.

A delegation from the Myanmar navy’s Ministry of Science and Technology final month studied a nuclear energy plant in Russia and inked some offers, based on Myanmar media Than Lwin Times. These agreements included a plan to construct a nuclear “technology hub” with a small reactor in Yangon, mentioned navy defector Captain Kaung Thu Win.

“The [Myanmar] military said they won’t use [the project] to make weapons. However, out of sight, it may produce weapons after the nuclear plant is built,” the defector famous, based on Than Lwin Times, warning that this could pose a big risk to folks in Myanmar.

Russia’s high-profile interactions with the generals haven’t gone unnoticed in China.

“Myanmar’s military government is currently shut out of most regional summits and sanctioned by several Western countries. Myanmar, being more and more isolated, has increasingly sought diplomatic support and armaments from Russia,” famous Chinese educational Lin Xixing in an evaluation printed earlier this yr. Lin was affiliated with Jinan University within the southern metropolis of Guangzhou and used to work within the Chinese authorities.

The Chinese scholar mentioned that “Myanmar’s diplomatic stance has completely shifted to Russia, and it has become more confident in the political game,” referring to the navy’s plan to carry an electoral train in 2023.

The pariah regime “seems to enjoy some measure of pragmatic acceptance by China and to a lesser extent India, and outright strong support by Russia”, famous a December 1 briefing paper by Joanne Lin and Moe Thuzar of the Singapore-based ISEAS-Yusof Ishak Institute.

Min Aung Hlaing has been fast to return the favour to each patrons.

His regime voiced assist for Russia’s invasion whereas the navy’s proxy get together, the Union Solidarity and Development Party (USDP), accused then-US House Speaker Nancy Pelosi of destabilising the area together with her go to to Taiwan in August.

A gaggle of worldwide legislators concluded final month, following a four-month inquiry, that “steadfast and uncritical” assist from Russia, China and India was enabling the navy to maintain itself regardless of the continued pushback by the anti-coup motion, together with armed fighters.

The NUG continues to throw its weight behind Kyaw Moe Tun.

“The NUG wholly stands behind Kyaw Moe Tun who has risen to the occasion and in this dark time has proven himself not only to be an ardent and tireless supporter of human rights and democracy, but also a very skilled and capable diplomat,” Dr Sasa, NUG’s Minister for International Cooperation, advised Al Jazeera.

“The military hope to control the international narrative, to suppress the truth, and to stalemate any nascent international response by ‘legitimising’ themselves through the credentials committee,” mentioned the minister, who spoke from an undisclosed location.

Anti-Coup Fighters And Protesters At A Rally In Myanmar'S Sagaing Region. They Are Shouting As They Walk. Some Have Weapons And One Is Carrying A Megaphone.
The Myanmar navy continues to face opposition to its rule, together with from civilian armed teams linked to the NUG [File: AFP]

Dr Sasa warns that accepting the navy’s nominee would most likely open the door to offering assist and doing enterprise with the generals “and of course, a PR blitz with photos of generals on the world stage”.

Despite assist for the NUG, the trail forward for its formal recognition stays unsure, the ISEAS paper mentioned.

Beijing and Moscow’s veto energy on the UN Security Council and differing preferences throughout the Association of Southeast Asian Nations might proceed to supply the regime “with the expectation that it could still pursue recognition and legitimacy via its plans for an election in 2023,” it noticed.