What do Russians actually consider Putin and Navalny?


As Vladimir Putin’s most outspoken home critic, Alexey Navalny, who’s at present serving a two-year-and-eight-month sentence in a Russian jail the place he has been described as being “seriously ill”, has turn into an internationally recognised figurehead of the nation’s opposition.

When he returned to Moscow from Germany in January, the place he had acquired therapy after being poisoned with a nerve agent, he was arrested at Moscow’s Sheremetyevo airport.

World leaders condemned his therapy and protests broke out throughout Russia from Kaliningrad to Vladivostok. Tens of 1000’s took to the streets and by the top of February, approximately 11,000 protesters had been detained.

Foreign media broadly labelled the protests as “pro-Navalny”, however does this narrative precisely mirror the temper on the bottom in Russia?

Al Jazeera spoke to 5 younger Russians who’ve little, if any, recollection of a Russia that wasn’t ruled by Vladimir Putin and requested them their views on each males.

Anna*, 19, Ekaterinburg  – ‘I just want my voice to be counted’

Anna is a 19-year-old undergraduate scholar on the Higher School of Economics (HSE) in St Petersburg. Like most college students, she is ready out the pandemic along with her dad and mom, having moved again to her hometown, 100km from Ekaterinburg. It is a small, conservative metropolis and even on the peak of protests in late January, demonstrations didn’t happen there.

But whereas she couldn’t take part within the protests, Anna says she helps those that did.

Since Navalny’s arrest, she has adopted Telegram channels that she describes as “anti-Putin”, however says that she believes the protests had been about neither Putin nor Navalny.

“Defenders of the Putin regime like to say that this [is] a confrontation between two figures and that [the] people who go out on the street want Navalny to be president,” she says.

“This is not true in fact. Although I have heard slogans at rallies such as ‘Navalny for president’, people come out because they are tired of the lies that they feed us every day.”

GettyImages 1230750121Protesters conflict with police at a rally in opposition to the jailing of Alexey Navalny in Moscow in January 2021 [File: Mikhail Svetlov/Getty Images]

Lack of political change is partly accountable for her frustrations. She believes the “office swap” between Putin and Dmitry Medvedev from 2008 to 2012 – when Medvedev grew to become president and Putin prime minister – solely gave the looks of Putin stepping apart when, in reality, he remained the true energy dealer in Russian politics. The president and, she argues, the entire administration, has by no means actually modified in her lifetime.

But regardless of being crucial of Putin, Anna doesn’t again Navalny as his successor.

“I think he is important now because he is a charismatic leader … Any revolution needs a leader, but it does not mean that this leader is a good one for the ‘new’, peaceful country. I would not like him to be a president,” she says.

Anna’s mistrust of Navalny comes from what she describes as his “all or nothing” approach to politics. She is especially suspicious of what she considers to be his use of emotive, divisive language as a manner of bolstering assist.

“I don’t assist his anti-migrant coverage. Navalny is a populist, he follows [the] temper of individuals. In Moscow, migration from near Eastern international locations is an issue, nevertheless it doesn’t imply [people] might be xenophobic or nationalist[ic] in direction of [them].

“He is quite controversial because he is talking about democracy and equal rights but at the same time, he is against people who come to Russia for many purposes,” she says.

Around the time of his arrest in January, a video Navalny had initially posted to his YouTube channel in 2007 resurfaced. In the pro-gun rights video, Navalny compares Muslims to flies and cockroaches. It concludes with Navalny “shooting” an actor posing as a Muslim who was about to “attack” him earlier than stating, “In such cases, I recommend a pistol.”

In February, Amnesty International stripped him of “prisoner of conscience” standing, saying that a few of his previous feedback “reached the threshold of advocacy of hatred”.

Despite her criticism of a few of Navalny’s insurance policies and views, Anna says she does assist his “opinion on freedom of speech and free mass media”.

Before talking to Al Jazeera, Anna says she checked her college’s insurance policies on college students talking to the press. She cited the case of Yegor Zhukov, a 22-year-old former scholar at HSE in Moscow. Last 12 months, Zhukov was charged with “inciting extremism” after a court-appointed linguistics knowledgeable acknowledged that his YouTube blogs known as for protests that might flip violent. He was given a three-year suspended sentence and banned from running a blog. In January, HSE launched new rules relating to political activism by its college students.

“I just want my voice to be counted and I want to not be afraid to express [an] opinion, and I definitely want our president to be changed more often than once in 20 years,” Anna displays.

“There is no justice in our country and there is no fairness. If you tell the truth, you are put in jail, if you peacefully express your position, you are beaten in the street by police officers and then put in jail.”

Galina*, 28, Moscow – ‘Russia will be free’

Galina is 28 years previous and works as an administrator at an IT firm in Moscow. Long annoyed by what she believes is corruption in Russian politics, for her, the protests in January had been the second for which she had been ready.

She attended protests in Moscow on January 23 and January 31, the place she says there have been approximately 10,000 to 15,000 demonstrators.

“I went out alone and I was scared, I had a backpack with everything necessary for the detention, I was preparing. No one I know has come out, everyone is afraid. They are afraid of criminal liability, they are afraid of losing their jobs or large fines,” she says.

Galina says she would depart the protests at any time when police approached the demonstrators.

“[The police brutality] was scary to watch on the internet, but it’s even scarier to see it live … People were beaten up in front of me.”

2021 04 02T095520Z 1681325316 RC2LNM9NS3Q1 RTRMADP 3 RUSSIA POLITICS NAVALNY TENDERSA riot police officer stands guard in entrance of the Kremlin after Alexey Navalny was given a two-and-a-half-year jail sentence in Moscow in February 2021 [Evgenia Novozhenina/Reuters]

Galina believes endemic high-level corruption grew to become rooted within the Russian financial system following then-President Boris Yeltsin’s mass privatisation marketing campaign of state property within the 1990s. Russia’s shock remedy transition to a market financial system noticed a choose few dramatically improve their wealth and political affect whereas, many argue, sowing the seeds for extreme financial inequality and corruption.

For many Russians, nonetheless, financial hardship seems to be worsening, with the worth of potatoes, for instance, growing by 40 % within the first 5 weeks of the 12 months. It was in opposition to this backdrop that Navalny’s “Putin’s Palace” documentary went viral in January. The 113-minute report concerning the $1.31bn property on the Black Sea coast, which the video says was paid for “with the largest bribe in history”, has been seen greater than 115 million instances. Putin has since mentioned that the palace doesn’t belong to him.

“In my opinion, [members of the current government] are thieves and crooks, they do not care about ordinary people. They only think about their own enrichment. We have such a rich country and such poor people, it’s terrible,” Galina says.

“I think that 80 percent of the protesters came out against the current government. Alexey is more like a symbol. The way he was treated shows that the authorities can do anything to anyone. And people are against it,” she says, including that she would love Navalny to be president and that “those who are now in power should be in prison, not him.”

“The attitude to Navalny is twofold. But everyone agrees that the fact they tried to poison him and then put him in jail is unjust and abnormal.”

The fundamental slogan of the protests, she says, was, “Russia will be free.”

For Galina, a free Russia means selection and freedom from corruption.

“People should not be afraid to speak out against the authorities. Elections must be fair. The people will have power, there will be a democracy and not an autocracy as it is now. Everything that is in our country belongs to us, the people. This is how it should be”.

2020 08 22T004936Z 1187805622 RC2OII9C21HS RTRMADP 3 RUSSIA POLITICS NAVALNY GERMANYMedics encompass Alexey Navalny in an ambulance in Omsk, Russia in August 2020 after a suspected poisoning [Alexey Malgavko/Reuters]

Svetlana*, 33, Switzerland – ‘I support Putin’

Svetlana grew up and studied in St Petersburg. Last 12 months, she moved to Switzerland and at present lives in a small city near the French border the place she works as a painter. A vocal supporter of Putin, she strongly condemns Navalny, and people calling for change in Russia.

“For Russia, Navalny has never been and never will be the solution to the problem, and most importantly, what is the problem? Russian society is now more than ever, a stable and strong society,” she says.

“There are issues that need to be resolved, and Putin’s team is doing an excellent job with this, especially considering the pandemic.”

Svetlana, like Anna, is very crucial of Navalny’s anti-migrant stance and nationalistic tendencies.

“Russia is a multinational state, on the territory of which [lives] more than 190 [nationalities],” she says.

As an instance of Navalny’s nationalist views, she quotes the concluding line of one other of Navalny’s 2007 movies – one wherein he’s dressed as a dentist and seems to check migrant staff to rotting tooth that needs to be eliminated, “We have the right to be [ethnic] Russians in Russia and we will defend this right.”

Svetlana believes life has improved for Russians throughout Putin’s tenure. “I support Putin. People do not just live better, [Putin] has radically changed life in Russia. Free education, medicine, development of science and technology,” she concludes.

Igor*, 24 and Dmitry*, 27 Moscow – ‘In Russia, citizens do not live, but survive’

Igor is a scholar at Moscow’s Institute of Economic Relations, and Dmitry is an engineer at a water therapy agency. Both are primarily based in Moscow, the place they play on the identical sports activities crew. Neither participated within the protests because of fear of acquiring felony data.

Igor says he wish to see Navalny take energy, explaining: “For me, he [would] be a good president, but not for very long.”

No chief ought to have the ability to rule for too lengthy, he says, referring to laws just lately signed into regulation that will permit 68-year-old Putin – who has already dominated for greater than twenty years – to doubtlessly stay in energy till 2036.

“If Navalny were president, I would like to see from him a new constitution … you need to start everything from scratch. I would like to see independent courts. Governors should be chosen by the people, not appointed by the president. Return a fixed-term presidency for one person, no more than two terms of four years, maximum eight years without the right to re-elect under any circumstances,” Igor says.

“We always need changes and substitutions of different posts in Russia. It is not normal that the same guy [has been] sitting there for 20 years”.

GettyImages 1193884752President Vladimir Putin speaks throughout his annual state of the nation tackle in Moscow in January 2020 [Andrey Rudakov/Bloomberg via Getty Images]

Igor believes that it was anger on the present management somewhat than assist for Navalny that motivated lots of the demonstrators. “People [are] going out into the streets, but it is not so much for Navalny as it is against Putin and his crimes,” he says, itemizing “the murder of [Russian opposition politician] Boris Nemtsov [in 2015], the murder of [journalist and Kremlin critic] Anna Politkovskaya [in 2006], the poisoning of Navalny, propaganda in the media, [and] censorship on state channels” as among the “crimes” which have angered the protesters.

“Navalny is the only representative of the opposition in Russia, therefore, the citizens of Russia don’t have a choice,” he provides.

Dmitry describes Navalny as a “real patriot” however says he doesn’t need to see him take workplace.

“I don’t support Navalny for president because for him [it is] only black and white,” he says.

Neither Igor nor Dimitry suppose Navalny ought to have been stripped of Amnesty’s prisoner of conscience standing. “Undoubtedly, Navalny is a prisoner of conscience in a country with rotten, criminal branches of government,” Igor insists.

They additionally say they assist Navalny’s coverage of decreasing migration to Russia, arguing that the federal government exploits migrant staff as a supply of low-cost labour.

“The influx of migrants gives rise to unemployment of the indigenous population of Russia. This is not nationalism, but a sober assessment of the situation in Russia,” Igor says.

“There are low salaries, expensive food, the number of hospitals is decreasing, medicine is becoming more expensive, interest on loans is growing,” he says, including, “In Russia, citizens do not live, but survive.”

*Names have been modified to guard identities.